Conservative Jewish Movement: Committee on Jewish Law and Standards of the Rabbinical Assembly
Approves Gay Ordination and Same-Sex Marriage
On December 6, 2006, the highest legal body in Conservative Judaism, the centrist movement in
worldwide Jewry, voted yesterday to allow the ordination of gay rabbis
and the celebration of same-sex commitment ceremonies.
The decision, which followed years of debate, was denounced by
traditionalists in the movement as an indication that Conservative
Judaism had abandoned its commitment to adhere to Jewish law, but celebrated by
others as a long-awaited move toward full equality for gay people.
But in a reflection of the divisions in the movement, the 25 rabbis on
the law committee passed three conflicting legal opinions: one in favor of
gay rabbis and unions, and two against.In doing so, the committee left it up to
individual synagogues to decide whether to accept or reject gay rabbis and
commitment ceremonies, saying that either course is justified according to Jewish law.
See links to full texts of responsas:
RIGHTIST
Rabbi Leonard Levy Responsa Link- 6 votes (Minority Opinion)
Rabbi Joel Roth Responsa Link- 13 votes (Majority opinion)
CENTRIST
Rabbis Elliot Dorff, Daniel Nevins & Avram Reisner Gay Ordination & Marriage Responsa Link- 13 votes (Majority opinion)
LEFTIST
Rabbi Gordon Tucker Responsa Link 7 votes (but defeated as a takkanah requiring 13 votes)
Rabbis Myron Geller, Robert Fine, & David Fine Responsa Link 6 votes (but defeated as a takkanah requiring 13 votes)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
California Likely Voters Approve Same-Sex Marriage (September 30, 2006)
Results reported on page 29 of newly released PPIC (Public Policy Institute of CA) poll:
Likely voters approve same-sex marriage 47% to 46% (first favorable plurality).
58% of Democratic likely voters approve
49% of Independent likely voters approve
|